ERISA Compliance: A Deep Dive for HR Professionals

May 15, 2024

Navigating the intricate waters of ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act) compliance is not merely a legal obligation for employers—it’s also a strategic advantage. 

In this guide, we’ll delve into the depths of ERISA compliance, decoding its complexities and offering practical insights for HR professionals. By understanding ERISA’s regulations and implementing effective compliance strategies, HR teams can protect their organizations from costly mistakes and gain a competitive edge in the marketplace.

Decoding ERISA for the HR Professional

ERISA’s regulations can often seem like a maze of complicated legal language, but for HR professionals, focusing on the key aspects relevant to benefits administration is crucial. 

We’ll break down the essential elements of ERISA, from plan documentation requirements to fiduciary responsibilities, providing clarity amidst the complexity. Understanding these fundamentals lays the groundwork for effective ERISA compliance management.

Common Compliance Mistakes

Despite its importance, ERISA compliance is rife with potential pitfalls. From failing to provide required disclosures to mishandling plan assets, there are numerous areas where employers can inadvertently fall out of compliance. 

One key case that serves as a warning to fiduciaries is the Johnson & Johnson Prescription Drug Costs Lawsuit. 

The employee-led class action lawsuit challenges J&J over alleged failures in negotiating lower prescription drug prices within their health plan, spotlighting the broader implications for fiduciary duty under ERISA. 

The alleged disregard for negotiating lower prescription prices ultimately led to millions of dollars in overpayments for generic drugs. Specifically, the lawsuit alleges that J&J’s self-funded health plans paid inflated prices to pharmacy benefit managers for many generic drugs, raising out-of-pocket costs for workers.

Instances like the one mentioned above, where fiduciary duties have been breached, bring to light significant issues for fiduciaries, including:

  1. Increased Scrutiny – Failures in fiduciary responsibilities often lead to heightened scrutiny of self-funded health plans, particularly concerning their interactions with pharmacy benefit managers and strategies for negotiating drug prices.
  2. Financial Risks – Breaching ERISA fiduciary duties can result in substantial financial consequences. Previous legal judgments serve as a warning for other employers regarding the financial risks associated with non-compliance with ERISA regulations.
  3. Reputational Concerns – Apart from financial implications, organizations face the risk of damage to their reputation. Such situations can influence other employers to prioritize ERISA compliance to avoid negative publicity and its potential effects on employee trust and morale.

Fiduciary Responsibilities Under ERISA

  1. Participant Welfare: Fiduciaries are obligated to manage the plan solely for the benefit of participants and beneficiaries.
  2. Prudent Decision-making: Fiduciaries must exercise prudence in their actions, carefully weighing risks and benefits, and diversifying plan investments to mitigate significant losses.
  3. Adherence to Plan Terms: Fiduciaries must comply with the terms outlined in plan documents, as long as they align with ERISA regulations.
  4. Conflict Avoidance: Fiduciaries must avoid conflicts of interest, refraining from transactions that favor related parties such as other fiduciaries, service providers, or the plan sponsor.

If for any reason, fiduciaries are unable to uphold their legal obligations, there are serious consequences associated.

Consequences of Breaching Fiduciary Duties

  1. Personal Liability: Fiduciaries who fail to uphold these responsibilities may be personally liable to compensate for any losses suffered by the plan.
  2. Restitution: Organizations may be compelled to return any profits obtained through improper utilization of plan assets.
  3. Legal Accountability: Courts possess the authority to take necessary measures against fiduciaries, including their removal, for breaching their ERISA duties.

Now that you’re familiar with the responsibilities required to maintain compliance and the ramifications for not complying, let’s dive into strategies you can use to ensure your organization is maintaining compliance.

Strategies for Maintaining Compliance

Maintaining ERISA compliance is not a one-time task — it’s an ongoing commitment. 

As an organization, it’s critical to ensure robust practices and procedures are in place. This includes:

  • Diligently documenting all decisions
  • Ensuring consistent compliance with ERISA regulations
  • Guaranteeing your documentation and communication fosters transparency not only with fiduciaries but also with employees impacted by your healthcare plan.

Additionally, it’s important to invest in fiduciary training to equip and empower individuals responsible for managing employee benefits plans. By re-introducing and adopting best practices, organizations are better able to safeguard the interests of plan participants. 

Lastly, effectively maintaining compliance also requires conducting regular audits. Below is how you can best prepare.

Preparing for ERISA Audits

The prospect of an ERISA audit can be daunting, but preparation is key to navigating the process with confidence. 

By understanding the audit process and assembling the necessary documentation in advance, HR professionals can streamline the audit experience and mitigate potential compliance issues.

To complete a successful audit, here are key items fiduciaries must prepare for:

  • 401k and employee benefits regulation
  • Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) compliance
  • Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) compliance
  • Employee timekeeping
  • Wage and hour compliance
  • Child labor law compliance
  • Wage deduction processes
  • Accurate payroll and recordkeeping 

Remember — necessary elements for an audit may vary depending on the specific circumstances of the plan and the requirements of the audit. It’s essential to work closely with auditors and legal advisors to ensure all necessary documentation and procedures are in place.

ERISA Compliance: A Recap

Understanding ERISA regulations is crucial for HR professionals. From plan documentation to fiduciary duties, clarity and understanding is crucial for effective compliance management. 

It’s critical to remember that compliance is riddled with potential pitfalls, as highlighted by the J&J Prescription Drug Costs Lawsuit. This case underscores the significance of fiduciary responsibility, shedding light on heightened scrutiny, financial risks and reputational concerns tied to ERISA breaches.

Fiduciaries must uphold specific responsibilities, including participant welfare, prudent decision-making, adherence to plan terms and conflict avoidance to successfully manage ERISA compliance. Failure to do so can lead to severe consequences, such as personal liability, restitution and legal accountability. 

It’s imperative to implement robust compliance strategies, including diligent documentation, consistent adherence to regulations, transparency in communication and investment in fiduciary training. 

By viewing compliance as an ongoing process that requires diligence, attention to detail and a proactive stance, HR professionals can safeguard their organizations and position them for long-term success. With the insights and strategies outlined in this guide, HR professionals can navigate the complexities of ERISA with confidence, ensuring compliance while unlocking the strategic advantages it offers.

For additional support navigating ERISA, click here to connect with the Totem Team.

Keep Exploring